К ВОПРОСУ О ЗАБЫТОЙ ПОЛЕМИКЕ (А. А. БОГДАНОВ — В. И. ЛЕНИН)

Александр Евгеньевич Рыбас

Authors

Александр Евгеньевич Рыбас St. Petersburg State University, 7–9, Universitetskaya nab., St. Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation

Abstract

Th e article provides an analysis of the philosophical content of the polemics between Bogdanov and Lenin which began aft er Bogdanov’s Empiriomonism had been published. Th e author criticizes the traditional approaches to studying this polemics as he believes they were one-sided because of their being politically or emotionally engaged. He proposes his own in-depth study of the essential problems which determined the subject of the philosophical discussion between Bogdanov and Lenin. It is proved that in spite of Bogdanov’s and Lenin’s philosophical positions being formally contrary they should be regarded as identical. It is concluded that Lenin’s criticism infl uenced Bogdanov’s views and resulted both in his thesis of the “end of philosophy” and in his attempt to substitute science — tektology — for philosophy. Refs 10.

Keywords:

Russian philosophy, empiriomonism, Bogdanov, Lenin, empiriocriticism, absolute, truth, objective reality, materialism

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Литература

Soboleva M. A. Bogdanov und der philosophische Diskurs in Russland zu Beginn des 20. Jahrhunderts. Zur Geschichte des russischen Positivismus. Hildesheim: Georg Olms Verlag 2007. 277 p.

Пинегина Л. А. Философские разногласия Ленина и Богданова // Альманах «Восток». 2004. №11(23). URL: http://www.situation.ru/app/j_art_676.htm (дата обращения: 5.12.2015).

Красный Гамлет. Опыт коллективного анализа творческого наследия Александра Богданова // Вестник Российской Академии наук. 1994. Т. 64. №8. С. 738–752.

Стэйла Д. Наука и революция: Рецепция эмпириокритицизма в русской культуре (1877– 1910) / пер. с итал. О. Поповой. М.: Академический Проект 2013. 363 с.

Ленин В. И. Материализм и эмпириокритицизм. Критические заметки об одной реакционной философии. М.: Политиздат 1989. 512 с.

Богданов А. А. Вера и наука (По поводу книги В. Ильина «Материализм и эмпириокритицизм») // Богданов А. А. Падение великого фетишизма: Современный кризис идеологии. М.: КРА- САНД 2010. 224 с.

Богданов А. А. Эмпириомонизм: Статьи по философии. М.: Республика 2003. 400 с.

Grille D. Lenins Rivale. Bogdanov und seine Philosophie. Köln: Verlag Wissenschaft und Politik 1966. 263 s.

Богданов А. А. Тектология. Всеобщая организационная наука. М.: Финансы 2003. 496 с.

Богданов А. А. Философия живого опыта: Материализм эмпириокритицизм диалектический материализм эмпириомонизм наука будущего. Популярные очерки. М.: КРАСАНД 2010. 272 с.

References

Soboleva M. A. Bogdanov und der philosophische Diskurs in Russland zu Beginn des 20. Jahrhunderts. Zur Geschichte des russischen Positivismus [Bogdanov and the Philosophical in Russia at the Beginning of the 20th Century. To the History of Russian Positivism]. Hildesheim Georg Olms Verlag 2007. 277 S. (In German)

Pinegina L. A. Filosofskie raznoglasija Lenina i Bogdanova [Lenin’s and Bogdanov’s Philosophical Views]. Al’manah «Vostok» [Almanac “Th e East”] 2004. № 11(23). Available at: http://www.situation.ru/ app/j_art_676.htm (accessed 5.12.2015).

Krasnyj Gamlet. Opyt kollektivnogo analiza tvorcheskogo nasledija Aleksandra Bogdanova [Red Hamlet. A Collective Analysis of Aleksandr Bogdanov’s Creative Heritage]. Vestnik Rossijskoj Akademii nauk [Bulletin of the Russian Academy of Sciences]1994 vol. 64 no. 8 pp. 738–752. (In Russian)

Stjejla D. Nauka i revoljucija: Recepcija jempiriokriticizma v russkoj kul’ture (1877–1910) [Science and Revolution: A Reception of Empirio-criticism in the Russian Culture (1877–1910)]. Translated from Italian by О. Popov. Мoscow Academic Project Publ. 2013. 363 p. (In Russian)

Lenin V. I. Materializm i jempiriokriticizm. Kriticheskie zametki ob odnoj reakcionnoj fi losofi i [Materialism and Empirio-criticism. Critical Comments on a Reactionary Philosophy]. Moscow Politizdat Publ. 1989. 512 p. (In Russian)

Bogdanov A. A. Vera i nauka (Po povodu knigi V. Il’ina «Materializm i jempiriokriticizm») [Faith and Science (Concerning the Book by V. Iljin “Materialism and Empirio-criticism”)]. Bogdanov A. A. Padenie velikogo fetishizma: Sovremennyj krizis ideologii [Bogdanov А. А. Th e Fall of the Great Fetishism: A Contemporary Crisis of ideology]. Moscow KRASAND Publ. 2010. 224 p. (In Russian)

Bogdanov A. A. Jempiriomonizm: Stat’i po fi losofi i [Empiriomonism: Articles on Philosophy]. Moscow Republic 2003. 400 p. (In Russian)

Grille D. Lenins Rivale. Bogdanov und seine Philosophie [Lenin’s Rival. Bogdanov and his Philosophy]. Köln Verlag Wissenschaft und Politik 1966. 263 p. (In German)

Bogdanov A. A. Tektologija. Vseobshhaja organizacionnaja nauka [Tectology: Universal Organization Science]. Moscow Finances 2003. 496 p. (In Russian)

Bogdanov A. A. Filosofi ja zhivogo opyta: Materializm jempiriokriticizm dialekticheskij materializm jempiriomonizm nauka budushhego. Populjarnye ocherki [Philosophy of Living Experience: Materialism Empirio-criticism Dialectical Materialism Empiriomonism Science of the Future. Popular Essays]. Moscow KRASAND Publ. 2010. 272 p. (In Russian)