The great Greek “charlatan”: Empedocles

Authors

  • Oleg V. Rudin Institute of Philosophy and Law of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 8, ul. Nikolaeva, Novosibirsk, 630090, Russian Federation

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu17.2022.105

Abstract

This article revises the views about Empedocles of Akragas. Even contemporaries of the thinker were confronted with the question of whether he was a great sage or a charlatan. The combination of “scientific” and prophetic knowledge embarrassed more than one generation of researchers, making them accuse Empedocles of superficial eclecticism or see him as an inconsistent representative of antique mechanical philosophy. With no intention to give a final answer to this question, the article suggests looking at this problem from a different angle by focusing more on the lifestyle of Empedocles and less on his theoretical provisions of philosophy. The first part of the article provides a brief outline of the history of the concept of “charlatanism” and considers the image of Empedocles as a Greek alazon. The internal motives of the political and public activity of Akragas accompanied by provocative behavior and claims to divine status are considered. It is suggested that the personality conflict of Empedocles, the discrepancy of external appearance and acts, is primarily due to pedagogical purposes and desire to deliver saving truths to his contemporaries who were mired in vices. The second part of the article deals with a hypothesis about breathing exercises of Empedocles. The main attention is paid to the 129 B (DK) and 100 B (DK) fragments, with an attempt to reconstruct the breathing practice of Empedocles as a thought technique aimed at gaining access to higher knowledge.

Keywords:

Empedocles, charlatanism, alazon, rhetoric, parrhesia, breathing exercise

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References

Литература

Gentilcore, D. (2006), Medical Charlatanism in Early Modern Italy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Черных, П.Я. (1990), Историко-этимологический словарь современного русского языка, т. 2, М.: Русский язык.

Rumor, M. (2017), There’s No Fool Like An Old Fool: The Mesopotamian Aluzinnu and its relationship to the Greek alazôn, Kaskal, no. 14, pp. 187–210.

MacDowell, D.M. (1987), The Meaning of Ἀλαζών, Owls to Athens: Essays on Classical Subjects Presented to Sir Kenneth Dover, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 287–292.

Гиппократ (1936), О священной болезни, в: Гиппократ, Избранные книги, ред. Карпов, В.П., М.: Биомедгиз, с. 493–514.

Жуана, Ж. (1997), Гиппократ, Ростов-на-Дону: Феникс

Сёмушкин, А.В. (1985), Эмпедокл, М.: Мысль.

Лебедев, А.В. (ред.) (1989), Фрагменты ранних греческих философов, ч. 1, М.: Наука.

Sellars, J. (2009), The Art of Living: The Stoics on the Nature and Function of Philosophy, London: Bristol Classical Press.

Бордмэн, Дж., Хэммонд, Н.-Дж.-Л., Льюис, Д.-М.и Оствальд, М. (ред.) (2011), Кембриджская история Древнего мира, т. IV: Персия, Греция и западное Средиземноморье. Ок. 525–479 гг. до н. э., М.: Ладомир.

Маркузон, В.Ф. (ред.) (1973), Всеобщая история архитектуры: в 12 т., т. 2: Архитектура античного мира (Греция и Рим), М.: Изд-во литературы по строительству

Бордмэн, Дж., Льюис, Д.-М., Дэвис, Дж.-К. и Оствальд, М. (ред.) (2014), Кембриджская история Древнего мира, т. V: Пятый век до нашей эры, М.: Ладомир.

Гатри, У.К.Ч. (2017), История греческой философии: в 6 т., т. II: Досократовская традиция от Парменида до Демокрита, СПб.: Владимир Даль.

Жмудь, Л.Я. (2002), Зарождение истории науки в Античности, СПб.: РХГИ.

Якубанис, Г. (1994), Эмпедокл: философ, врач, чародей. Смерть Эмпедокла, Киев: Синто.

Жмудь, Л.Я. (1994), Наука, философия и религия в раннем пифагореизме, СПб.: Алетейя.

Гарин, С.В. (2014), Пερὶ τοῦ καιροῦ: Горгий и ранняя сицилийская риторика, Lingua mobilis: научный журнал, № 49, с. 45–53.

Фуко, М. (2014), Мужество истины. Управление собой и другими II, СПб.: Наука.

Фуко, М. (2020), Речь и истина. Лекции о парресии (1982–1983), М.: Издательский дом «Дело» РАНХиГС.

Ницше, Ф. (2013), Полное собрание сочинений: в 13 т., т. 1/2: Несвоевременные размышления. Из наследия 1872–1873 гг., М.: Культурная Революция.

Vernant, J.-P. (2006), Myth and Thought Among the Greeks, New York: Zone Books.

Адо, П. (1999), Что такое античная философия?, М.: Изд-во гуманитарной литературы.

Macris, C. and Skarsouli P. (2012), La sagesse et les pouvoirs du mystérieux τις du fragment 129 d’Empédocle, Revue de métaphysique et de morale, no. 75, p. 357–377.

Онианс, Р. (1999), На коленях богов, М.: Прогресс — Традиция

Афонасина, А.С. (2015), Эмпедокл о дыхании, ΣΧΟΛΗ, т. 9, вып. 2, с. 353–362

Гаспаров, М.Л. (ред.) (1999), Элинские поэты VII–III вв. до н. э. Эпос. Элегия. Ямбы. Мелика, М.: Ладомир.

Элиаде, М. (2019), Йога: бессмертие и свобода, М.: Академический проект.


References

Gentilcore, D. (2006), Medical Charlatanism in Early Modern Italy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Chernykh, P. (1990), Historical and etymological dictionary, vol. 2, Moscow: Russkii iazyk Publ. (In Russian)

Rumor, M. (2017), There’s No Fool Like An Old Fool: The Mesopotamian Aluzinnu and its relationship to the Greek alazôn, Kaskal, no. 14, pp. 187–210.

MacDowell, D.M. (1987), The Meaning of Ἀλαζών, Owls to Athens: Essays on Classical Subjects Presented to Sir Kenneth Dover. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 287–292.

Hippocrates (1936), On the Sacred Disease, in: Hippocrates, Izbrannye knigi, ed. by Karpov, V.P., Moscow: Biomedgiz Publ., pp. 493–514. (In Russian)

Jouanna, J. (1997), Hippocrates, Rostov-na-Donu: Feniks Publ. (In Russian)

Semushkin, A.V. (1985), Empedocles, Moscow: Mysl’ Publ. (In Russian)

Lebedev, A.V. (ed.) (1989), Pieces of Early Greek Philosophers, pt 1, Moscow: Nauka Publ. (In Russian)

Sellars, J. (2009), The Art of Living: The Stoics on the Nature and Function of Philosophy, London: Bristol Classical Press.

Boardman, J., Hammond, N.G.L., Lewis, D.M. and Ostwald, M. (eds) (2011), The Cambridge Ancient History, vol. 4: Persia, Greece and the Western Mediterranean с. 525 to 479 B.C., Moscow: Ladomir Publ. (In Russian)

Markuzon, V.F. (ed.) (1973), A general history of architecture in 12 vol., vol. 2: Architecture of the Ancient World (Greece and Rome), Moscow: Izdatel’stvo literatury po stroitel’stvu. (In Russian)

Boardman, J., Hammond, N.G.L., Lewis, D.M. and Ostwald, M. (eds) (2011), The Cambridge Ancient History, vol. 5: The Fifth Century B.C., Moscow: Ladomir Publ. (In Russian)

Guthrie, W.K.C. (2017), A History of Greek Philosophy, vol. 2: The Presocratic Tradition from Parmenides to Democritus, St Petersburg: Vladimir Dal’ Publ. (In Russian)

Zhmud, L. (2002), The Origin of the History of Science in Classical Antiquity, St Petersburg: RKhGI Publ. (In Russian)

Iakubanis, G. (1994), Empedocles: philosopher, physician, fascinator. Death of Empedocles, Kiev: Sinto Publ. (In Russian)

Zhmud, L. (1994), Science, Philosophy and Religion in Early Pythagorean Thought, St Petersburg: Aleteiia Publ. (In Russian)

Garin, S.V. (2014), Pερὶ τοῦ καιροῦ: Gorgias and early Sicilian rhetoric, Lingua mobilis: nauchnyi zhurnal, no. 49, pp. 45–53. (In Russian)

Foucault, M. (2014), The Courage of the Truth. The Government of Self and Others II, St Petersburg: Nauka Publ. (In Russian)

Foucault, M. (2020), Discourse and truth and lectures on parresia (1982–1983), Moscow: Izdatel’skii dom «Delo» RANKhiGS. (In Russian)

Nietzsche, F. (2013), Complete Works: in 13 vols, vol. 1/2: Untimely Meditations. From the heritage of 1872–1873, Moscow: Kul’turnaia Revoliutsiia. (In Russian)

Vernant, J.-P. (2006), Myth and Thought Among the Greeks, New York: Zone Books.

Hadot, P. (1999), What is Ancient Philosophy?, Moscow: Izdatel’stvo gumanitarnoi literatury. (In Russian)

Macris, C. and Skarsouli, P. (2012), La sagesse et les pouvoirs du mystérieux τις du fragment 129 d’Empédocle, Revue de métaphysique et de morale, no. 75, pp. 357–377.

Onians, R. (1999), On the Knees of the Gods, Moscow: Progress — Traditsiia Publ. (In Russian)

Afonasina, A. S. (2015), Empedocles on breathing, ΣΧΟΛΗ, vol. 9, iss. 2, pp. 353–362. (In Russian)

Gasparov, M.L. (ed.) (1999), Greek Poets of 7th–3rd Cent. B.C.Epic Poetry. Elegy. Iambic Poetry. Melic Poetry, Moscow: Ladomir Publ. (In Russian)

Eliade, M. (2019), Yoga: Immortality and Freedom, Moscow: Akademicheskii proekt Publ. (In Russian)

Вестник Санкт-Петербургского университета. Философия и конфликтология, Том 38, No 1, 2022

Downloads

Published

2022-06-16

How to Cite

Rudin, O. V. (2022). The great Greek “charlatan”: Empedocles. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies, 38(1), 52–63. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu17.2022.105

Issue

Vol. 38 No. 1 (2022): Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies

Section

Philosophy

License

Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.