WOMEN’S SUBJECTIVITY IN THE MIRROR OF NON-CLASSICAL STAGE DANCE OF 20th AND 21st CENTURIES

Authors

  • Наталия Валерьевна Курюмова University for Humanities, 3, ul. Zheleznodorozhnikov, Yekaterinburg, 620041, Russian Federation;
  • Галина Андреевна Брандт University for Humanities, 3, ul. Zheleznodorozhnikov, Yekaterinburg, 620041, Russian Federation;

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu17.2017.413

Abstract

The article considers how the concept of woman’s subjectivity brought into focus in feminist critics of the 20th century was evoked in non-classical dance of the 20th and 21st centuries. The authors’ goal is to prove that artistic experiences of modern dance, followed by contemporary dance, became the productive form of woman’s writing, the most fruitful “location” where woman’s subjectivity was manifested, from the feminist theorists’ point of view. The authors saw their principal task as examining the history of the interest that outstanding choreographers of the 20th century developed in seeking woman’s subjectivity “buried” in the body. The methodological frameworks integrated historical and typological, philosophical, culturological, deconstructive, and gender analyses. The article distinguishes several major trends, they are: the Delsarte’s American studies of expressive body acting of the suffragist epoch (Loïe Fuller, Isadora Duncan, Mod Allan), German expressionist dance, American modern dance and the Russian rhythmic and plastic dance of the first half of the 20th century (Marie Wiegmann, Martha Graham); the European Dance Theatre movement of the 1970s, that was the period of the second wave of feminism (Pina Bausch). It is stated that at the close of the 20th century and the early 21st century the brightest examples of the discussed theme are the artistic works deconstructing the concept of “woman’s subjectivity”. The analysis of the world famous performance “Co(te)lette” made by Anna van den Broek, a Dutch choreographer, presents a clear illustration of this observation. Then, using the example of creative works by Marie Chouinard (Canada), Mats Ek (Sweden), Matthew Bourne (Great Britain), the authors show how the plastic discourse of contemporary dance is gradually transferred from the area of feminist rhetoric to the field studying various gender perversions. In conclusion, as the authors stance, the example of Ivo Dimchev performances demonstrates that in contemporary dance the theme of woman’s subjectivity blurs and the attention focuses on the man with “strange’ (queer) gender identity, with floating unstable uncertain feeling of belonging to being. Refs 19.

Keywords:

woman’s subjectivity, corporeality, sex, feminism, performative theory of gender, queer theory, nonclassical dance, modern dance, contemporary dance, male view, woman’s writing

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References

Литература

Кемеров В. Е. Субъект субъективность субъектность // Современный философский словарь / под общ. ред. проф. В. Е. Кемерова. 2-е изд. испр и доп. Лондон; Франкфурт-на-Майне; Париж; Люксембург; Москва; Минск: ПАНПРИНТ 1998. С. 884–885.

Фрейд З. Тридцать третья лекция: Женственность // Фрейд З. Введение в психоанализ. Лекции. М.: Наука 1989. С. 369–384.

Брандт Г. А. Современный феминизм: переворот в историко-философской антропологиче- ской традиции Западной Европы // АДАМ И ЕВА. Альманах гендерной истории / под ред. Л. П. Ре- пиной. М.: ИВИ РАН 2003. № 6. С. 148–198.

Бовуар С. де. Второй пол / пер. с франц. общ. ред. и вступ. ст. С. Г. Айвазовой коммент. М. В. Аристовой. М.: Прогресс; СПб.: Алетейя 1997. 832 с.

Cixous H. The Laugh of the Medusa // Women’s Voices. Visions and Perspectives / ed. by P. C. Hoy II E. H. Schor R. Di Yanni. New York: McGray-Hill Publishing Company 1990. P. 481–496.

Cixous H. Castration or Decapitation? // Signs Journal of Women in Culture and Society. University of Chicago Press 1981. N 1. P. 448–491.

Иригарэ Л. Пол который не единичен // Введение в гендерные исследования. Ч. II: Хрестома- тия / под ред. С. В. Жеребкина. Харьков: ГЦСИ; СПб.: Алетейя 2001. С. 127–135.

Olbright A. C. Choreographing difference: the body and Identy in Contemporary Dance. Middletown USA: Wesleyan University Press 1997. 216 p.

Суриц Е. Я. Балет и танец в Америке: очерки истории. Екатеринбург: Изд-во Уральского ун-та 2004. 392 с.

Дункан А. Танец будущего // Дункан А. Танец будущего. Моя жизнь. И. Шнейдер. Встречи с Есениным. Ростов н/Д: Феникс 1998. С. 5–14.

Anderson J. Art without boundearies. Iowa city: University of Iowa Press 1993. 346 p.

Фокин М. М. Против течения. Воспоминания балетмейстера. Статьи. Письма / ред.-сост. авт. вст. ст. Ю. И. Слонимский. Л.; М.: Искусство 1962. 640 с.

Хлопова В. The great Martha // Nofixedpoints: авторский сайт посвященный современному танцу. URL: http://nofixedpoints.com/marthagraham (дата обращения: 16.07. 2016).

Гердт О. Пина Бауш — ничья // Театр: российский театральный журнал. 2010. № 1. C. 6–20.

Broek Ann van den. Repertoire // Wardward.be: a site dedicated to the work of the choreographer. URL: http://www.wardward.be/e-choreo-wesolomen.html (дата обращения: 15.11.2016).

Бодрийяр Ж. Общество потребления. М.: Республика; Культурная революция 2006. 167 с.

Балашов В. Хлеб жизни и искусства. Предисловие // Колетт С.-Г. Четыре романа / пер. с франц.; редкол.: Т. Балашов Д. Затонский С. Никольский и др. М.: Художественная литература 1987. С. 5–22.

Батлер Дж. Гендерное беспокойство // Антология гендерной теории. Сб. пер. / сост. и коммент. Е. Гаповой А. Усмановой. Минск: Пропилеи 2000. С. 28–47

Лауретис де Т. Американский Фрейд // Введение в гендерные исследования. Ч. II: Хрестоматия / под ред. С. В. Жеребкина. Харьков: ГЦСИ; СПб.: Алетейя 2001. С. 23–62.

References

Kemerov V. E. Sub”ekt, sub”ektivnost’, sub”ektnost’ [Subject, subjectivity, subjectivity]. Sovremennyi filosofskii slovar’ [Modern philosophical dictionary], under the general editorship of Professor V. E. Kemerov. 2nd ed., corrected and amended. London, Frankfurt, Paris, Luxembourg, Moscow, Minsk, PANPRINT Publ., 1998, pp. 884–885. (In Russian)

Freud Z. Tridtsat’ tret’ia lektsiia: Zhenstvennost’ [Thirty-third lecture: Femininity]. Freud Z. Vvedenie v psikhoanaliz. Lektsii [Introduction to psychoanalysis. Lectures]. Moscow Nauka Publ.1989 pp. 369–384. (In Russian)

Brandt G. A. Sovremennyi feminizm: perevorot v istoriko-filosofskoi antropologicheskoi traditsii Zapadnoi Evropy [Modern feminism: a revolution in the historical and philosophical anthropological tradition of Western Europe]. ADAM I EVA. Al’manakh gendernoi istorii [ADAM AND EVE. Almanac of gender history]. Ed. by L. P. Repina. Moscow Institute of Oriental Studies Russian Academy of Sciences Publ.2003 no. 6 pp. 148–198. (In Russian)

Beauvoir S. de. Vtoroi pol [Second sex]. Transl. from French ed. by S. G. Aivazova comment. M. V. Aristova. Moscow Progress Pdl.; St. Petersburg Aleteiia Publ. 1997. 832 p. (In Russian)

Cixous H. The Laugh of the Medusa. Women’s Voices. Visions and Perspectives. Ed. by Pat C. Hoy II E. H. Schor R. Di Yanni. New York McGray-Hill Publishing Company1990 pp. 481–496.

Cixous H. Castration or Decapitation? Signs Journal of Women in Culture and Society. University of Chicago Press1981 no. 1 pp. 448–491.

Irigare L. Pol kotoryi ne edinichen [This sex which is not a single]. Vvedenie v gendernye issledovaniia [Introduction to gender studies]. Part II: Reader ed. by S. V. Zherebkin. Khar’kov GTsSI Publ. St. Petersburg Aleteiia Publ.2001 pp. 127–135. (In Russian)

Olbright A. C. Choreographing difference: the body and Identy in Contemporary Dance. USA Middletown Wesleyan University Press 1997. 216 p.

Surits E. Ia. Balet i tanets v Amerike: ocherki istorii [Ballet and dance in America: essays of history]. Ekaterinburg Publishing House of the Ural University 2004. 392 p. (In Russian)

Duncan I. Tanets budushchego [Dance of the Future]. Dunkan I. Tanets budushchego. Moia zhizn’. I. Shneider. Vstrechi s Eseninym [Duncan I. Dance of the future. My life. Schneider I. Meetings with Yesenin]. Rostov on Don Feniks Publ.1998 pp. 5–14. (In Russian)

Anderson J. Art without boundearies. Iowa sity University of Iowa press 1993. 346 p.

Fokin M. M. Protiv techeniia. Vospominaniia baletmeistera. Stat’i. Pis’ma [Against the Current. Memoirs of the choreographer. Articles. Letters]. Leningrad Moscow Iskusstvo Publ. 1962. 640 p. (In Russian)

Khlopova V. The great Martha. Nofixedpoints: author’s site dedicated to contemporary dance. Available at: http://nofixedpoints.com/marthagraham (accessed: 16.07. 2016). (In Russian)

Gerdt O. Pina Baush — nich’ia [Pina Bausch — dead head]. Teatr: rossiiskii teatral’nyi zhurnal2010 no. 1 pp. 6–20. (In Russian)

Broek Ann van den. Repertoire. Wardward.be: a site dedicated to the work of the choreographer. Available at: http://www.wardward.be/e-choreo-wesolomen.html (accessed: 15.11.2016).

Baudrillard J. Obshchestvo potrebleniia [Consumer Society]. Moscow Respublika Publ. Kul’turnaia revoliutsiia Publ. 2006. 167 p. (In Russian)

Balashov V. Khleb zhizni i iskusstva. Predislovie [Bread of life and art. Foreword]. Colette S.- G. Chetyre romana [Four novels]. Transl. from French eds by T. Balashov D. Zatonsky S. Nikolsky and others. Moscow Khudozhestvennaia literatura Publ.1987 pp. 5–22. (In Russian)

Butler Ju. Gendernoe bespokoistvo [Gender Trouble]. Antologiia gendernoi teorii. Sbornik perevodov [Anthology of gender theory. Digest of translations]. Comp. and comments by E. Gapova A. Usmanova. Minsk Propilei2000 pp. 28–47. (In Russian)

Lauretis T. de. Amerikanskii Freid [American Freud]. Vvedenie v gendernye issledovaniia [Introduction to gender studies]. Pt. II. Reader ed. by S. V. Zherebkin. Khar’kov GTsSI Publ. St. Petersburg Aleteiia Publ.2001 pp. 23–62. (In Russian)

Published

2018-10-03

How to Cite

Курюмова, Н. В., & Брандт, Г. А. (2018). WOMEN’S SUBJECTIVITY IN THE MIRROR OF NON-CLASSICAL STAGE DANCE OF 20th AND 21st CENTURIES. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies, 33(4), 552–562. https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu17.2017.413