The idea of god-building in the history of Russian thought

Authors

  • Александр Александрович Ермичёв The Russian Christian Academy for Humanities

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu17.2019.202

Abstract

The article reviews the idea of God-building in the ranks of the Bolshevik party in the early twentieth century, as well as in Russian thought. The main principles of this idea are atheism, humanism, and rationalism. For the first time God-building is analyzed not only as innerparty
strife, but as a possible way to solve the traditional puzzles of God-world, transcendentimmanent, and religious-social relationships. On the one hand, the context for its emergence was social Christianity (as a compromise of the God-world problem), and on the other,the number of attempts by certain Narodniks to employ the religious form of cognition for the liberation movement. The rise of God-building and related ideas is directly connected with the extraordinary social circumstances of the early twentieth century in Russia (a decade of Narodniks, the revolutionary situation of the beginning of the century, and the 1905 revolution), when secular humanism was especially popular. The article analyses the philosophical foundations and main principles (atheism, scientism, and egalitarianism) of the “New Religion” of the prominent Narodnik Bervi-Flerovskii, who is considered the direct ancestor of God-building ideas that he proposed as a mindset for those who support progressive development in Russia. Further, a distinction between Bervi-Flerovskii’s “philosophy of communism” and God-building of Gorkii and Lunacharskii is emphasised. The assertion is that the Godbuilding ideas of Gorkii and Lunacharskii revealed the pseudo-religious content of Marxism.

Keywords:

religion, social Christianity, God-building, God-seeking, the revolutionary Narodniks, «The New Religion», Marxism as pseudo-religion, A. M. Gorky, A. V. Lunacharsky, V. V. Bervi-Flerovsky

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

Author Biography

Александр Александрович Ермичёв, The Russian Christian Academy for Humanities

Dr. Sci. in Philosophy, Professor.

References

Литература

1. Луначарский А. В. Религия и социализм. Ч. 1. СПб.: Шиповник, 1908. 230 с.

2. Луначарский А. В. Будущее религии // Образование. 1907. № 10. Вторая паг. С. 1–25.

3. Горький А. М. Десять лет // Горький А. М. Собр. соч.: в 30 т. М.: Гос. изд-во худ. лит., 1953. Т. 24. С. 285–293.

4. Луначарский А. В. Свет во тьме. Литературный распад и концентрация интеллигенции // Луначарский А. В. Критические этюды. Русская литература. Л.: Изд-во Книжного сектора Ленгубоно, 1925. С. 102–121.

5. Горький М. [Письмо] Г. А. Алексинскому 16 (29) мая 1908. Капри // Горький М. Полн. собр. соч. Письма: в 24 т. М.: Наука, 2000. Т. 6: Письма 1917 — август 1908. С. 240–242.

6. Луначарский А. В. Великий переворот. Пг.: Изд-во З. И. Гржебина, 1919. 100 с.

7. Мережковский Д. С. Чехов и Горький // Мережковский Д. С. Не мир, но меч. Харьков; М.: АСТ; Фолио, 2000. С. 327–375.

8. Флоровский Г. Пути русского богословия. Париж: YMCA Press, 1988. 600 с.

9. Жилкин И. В. Странички жизни // Слово. 1908. № 622, 16 (29) ноября. С. 4.

10. Булгаков С. Н. Героизм и подвижничество // Вехи. Сборник статей о русской интеллигенции. Свердловск: Изд-во УрГУ, 1991. С. 26–68.

11. Берви-Флеровский В. В. Три политические системы. Николай I-ый, Александр II-ой, Александр III-ий. Воспоминания Н. Флеровского. [Лондон: Б. и.], 1897. 543 с.

12. [Берви-Флеровский В. В.] На жизнь и на смерть. Изображение идеалистов. Роман в трех частях. Geneve; Bale; Lyon, 1877. Ч. I — 209 с.; ч. II — 235 с.; ч. III — 190 с.

13. Берви-Флеровский В. В. Азбука социальных наук. XVII и XVIII века современной западно-европейской цивилизации. Лондон: Фонд вольной русской прессы, 1894. 130 с.

14. Берви-Флеровский В. В. Азбука социальных наук. XIX век современной западноевропейской цивилизации. Лондон: Фонд вольной русской прессы, 1894. III + 235 с.

15. Берви-Флеровский В. В. Азбука социальных наук. Современная западноевропейская цивилизация. Греко-римская цивилизация, средние века. Возрождение наук. Лондон: Фонд вольной русской прессы, 1894. 147 + 19 с.

16. Струве П. Б. Facies Hippocratica. К характеристике кризиса в современном социализме// Струве П. Б. Patriotica: политика, культура, религия, социализм. М.: Республика, 1997. С. 314–324.

References

1. Lunacharskiy, A. V. (1908), Religiya i sotsialism [Religion and socialism], vol. 1, Shipovnik Publ., St. Petersburg, Russia. (In Russian)

2. Lunacharskiy, A. V. (1907), Budustchee religii [The future of Religion], in Obrazovanie, no. 10, pp. 1–25. (In Russian)

3. Gorkiy, M. (1953), “Desiat’ let” [Ten years], in Gorkiy, M. Sobranie sochineniy [Сollected works], in 30 vols., vol. 24, Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo khudozhestvennoi literatury Publ., Moscow, Russia, pp. 285–293. (In Russian)

4. Lunacharskiy, A. V. (1925), “Svet vo t’me. Literaturnyi raspad i kontsentratsiia intelligentsii” [Light in the darkness. Literary decay], in Lunacharskiy, A. V. Kriticheskie etiudy. Russkaia literatura [Critical es says. Russian literature], Izdatel’stvo Knizhnogo sektora Lengubono Publ., Moscow, Russia, pp. 102–121.(In Russian)

5. Gorkiy, M. (2000), “Pis’mo G. A. Aleksinskomu 16 (29) maia 1908. Kapri” [Letter to G. A. Aleksinskiy, May, 16 (29) 1908], in Gorkiy, M. Polnoje sobranie sochineniy. Pisma v 24 tomakh [Complete works. Letters in 24 vols.], vol. 6, Nauka Publ., Moscow, Russia, pp. 240–242. (In Russian)

6. Lunacharskiy, A. V. (1919), Velikii perevorot [The great upheaval], Izdatel’stvo Z. I. Grzhebina Publ., Petrograd, Russia. (In Russian)

7. Merezhkovskiy, D. S. (2000), “Chekhov i Gor’kii” [Chekhov and Gorkiy], in Merezhkovskiy, D. S. Nemir, no mech [Not peace, but sword], AST Publ., Folio Publ., Kharkiv, Ukraine, Moscow, Russia, pp. 327–375. (In Russian)

8. Florovskiy, G. (1988), Puti russkogo bogosloviia [The paths of a Russian teology], YMCA Press, Paris,France. (In Russian)

9. Zhilkin, I. (1908), “Stranichki zhizni” [Pages of life], Slovo, no. 622, 16 (29) November, р. 4. (In Russian)

10. Bulgakov, S. (1991), “Geroizm i podvizhnichestvo” [Heroism and asceticism], in Vekhi. Sbornik statei o russkoi intelligentsii [Landmarks. A collection of essays on the Russian Intelligentsia], Izdatel’stvo UrGU Publ., Sverdlovsk, Russia, pp. 26–68. (In Russian)

11. Bervi-Flerovskiy, V. V. (1897), Tri politicheskie sistemy. Nikolai I-yi, Aleksandr II-oi, Aleksandr III-ii. Vospominaniia N. Flerovskogo [Three political systems. Nicholas I, Alexander II, Alexander III. Flerovskiy’s recollections], s. l., London, UK. (In Russian)

12. Bervi-Flerovskiy, V. V. (1877), Na zhizn’ i na smert’ [For the life and for the death], 3 pts., Geneve, Bale, Lyon. (In Russian)

13. Bervi-Flerovskiy, V. V. (1894), Azbuka sotsial’nykh nauk. XVII i XVIII veka sovremennoi zapadnoevropeiskoi tsivilizatsii [The hornbook of social sciences. 17th and 18th centuries of the modern western European civilization], Fond vol’noi russkoi pressy Publ., London, UK. (In Russian)

14. Bervi-Flerovskiy, V. V. (1894), Azbuka sotsial’nykh nauk. XIX vek sovremennoi zapadno-evropeiskoi tsivilizatsii [The hornbook of social sciences. 19th century of the modern western European civilization], Fond vol’noi russkoi pressy Publ., London, UK. (In Russian)

15. Bervi-Flerovskiy, V. V. (1894), Azbuka sotsial’nykh nauk. Sovremennaia zapadnoevropeiskaia tsivilizatsiia. Greko-rimskaia tsivilizatsiia, srednie veka. Vozrozhdenie nauk [The hornbook of social sciences. The modern western European civilization. Greco-Roman civilization, Middle Ages. Renaissance of science], Fond vol’noi russkoi pressy Publ., London, UK. (In Russian)

16. Struve, P. (1997), “Facies Hippocratica. K kharakteristike krizisa v sovremennom sotsializme” [Facies Hippocratica. On the characteristics of the crisis in the contemporary socialism], in Struve, P. Patriotica: politika, kul’tura, religiia, sotsializm [Patriotica: politics, culture, religion, socialism], Respublika Publ., Moscow, Russia, p. 314–324. (In Russian)

17. Struve, P. (1997), “Religiia i sotsializm” [Religion and socialism], in Struve, P., Patriotica: politika,kul’tura, religiia, sotsializm [Patriotica: politics, culture, religion, socialism], Respublika Publ., Moscow, Russia,p. 325–333. (In Russian)

Downloads

Published

2019-11-21

How to Cite

Ермичёв, А. А. (2019). The idea of god-building in the history of Russian thought. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies, 35(2), 250–263. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu17.2019.202

Issue

Vol. 35 No. 2 (2019): Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies

Section

Philosophy

License

Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.