“Women’s issue” in Orthodoxy: discussions in the second half of 20th — 21st century
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu17.2019.116Abstract
The purpose of this article is to analyze how the question of women’s position in Orthodoxy entered the international agenda and how it became the subject of theological discussions within the Orthodox churches, which theologically significant principles were worked out during the discussion. The issue of women’s position in the church began to be considered in the context of the ecumenical dialogue and began to be discussed in the World Council of Churches since the moment of its emergence in the context of growing attention to human rights and dignity and the ceasing of discrimination against women. The emerging practice of the ordination of women in the Protestant churches in Europe prompted the WCC to collect a spectrum of theological positions on this issue of the WCC member churches.
“The Ecumenical Decade 1988–1998: Churches in Solidarity with Women” demonstrated the severe confrontation of Protestant and Orthodox churches in the WCC, and not only in relation to the attitude to the women’s ordination, but to the issue of violence as well. The WCC stimulated in the middle of 1970s the conduct of regular inter-Orthodox meetings — conferences, where various aspects such as theological, social and cultural, determining the position of women were discussed. The largest was the conference held in 1988 in Rhodes “The Place of the Woman in the Orthodox Church and the Ordination of Women”; the next step in the theological interpretation of this issue was the conference in Thessaloniki in 2015 “Deaconesses, Or dination of Women and Orthodox Theology”. The argumentation of the Orthodox churches’ position has endured a serious evolution. If initially the thesis that the Orthodox Church does not know the practice of women’s ordination prevailed, and the prohibition for women to participate in the rituals is rooted in ecclesiology and christology, during the discussions were articulated the arguments showing convincingly that in the ancient church women were being ordained deaconesses and various forms of women’s church activity were practiced.
Keywords:
gender and religion, history of women, orthodox women, ecumenical dialogue, inter-orthodox relations, World Council of Churches, women rights
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Литература/ References
Белякова Е. В., Белякова Н. А., Емченко Е. Б. Женщина в православии: церковное право и российская практика. М.: Кучково поле, 2011. 704 с.
Barot M. Cooperation entre les hommes et les femmes dans l’Eglise, la famille et la Societe. Broshures d’Information sue se departament, Geneva: COE, 1964. 20 p.
Limouris G. Orthodox and ecumenical Assemblies and Conferences of the XX century // Kanon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. 2000. Bd. XVI. S. 1–24.
Кунтер К. Был ли третий путь? Всемирный совет церквей в период холодной войны // Государство, религия, церковь в России и за рубежом. 2017. № 1. С. 147–163.
Бер-Сижель Э., Каллист (Уэр), епископ Диоклийский. Рукоположение женщин в Православной церкви. М.: ББИ, 2000. 81 с.
Parvey C. F. The Community of Women and Men in the Church. The Sheffield Report. Geneve: WCC, 1983. 201 p.
Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry. World Council of Churches. Faith and Order. Paper No. 111 // WCCCOE. ORG: сайт Всемирного совета церквей. 1982. URL: https://www.oikoumene.org/en/resources/documents/commissions/faith-and-order/i-unity-the-church-and-its-mission/baptism-eucharist-andministry-faith-and-order-paper-no-111-the-lima-text (дата обращения: 08.02.2018).
Was ist und was soll eine “Okumenische Dekade Solidaritat der Kirchen mit den Frauen”? Informationsund Studienheft fur die evangelische Landeskirche in Wurttemberg. Wurttemberg: Evangelischen Landeskirche in Wurttemberg, 1996. 78 S.
Brown S. “Churches accused of ignoring or condoning violence against women” // ARCHIVE. WFN.ORG: Сервер Worldwide Faith News archives. Ecumenical News International. 1999.04.01. URL: http://archive.wfn.org/1999/01/msg00030.html (дата обращения: 11.02.2018).
WCC Assembly Debates Role of Women. WCC Eighth Assembly — Press Release N 16. 7 December // WCC-COE. ORG: сервер Всемирного совета церквей. 1998. URL: http://wcc-coe.org/wcc/assembly/pre-16.html (дата обращения: 11.02.2018).
Заключительный отчет Специальной комиссии по вопросу об участии Православных Церквей в работе Всемирного Совета Церквей // WCC-COE. ORG: сервер Всемирного совета церквей. 2002. URL: http://wcc-coe.org/wcc/russian.html (дата обращения: 11.02.2018).
Liveris L. B. Ancient Taboos and Gender Prejudice: Challenges for Orthodox Women and the Church. Abingdon: Routledge, 2005. 254 p.
Kasselouri M., Pekridou М. Many Women Were Also There: The Participation of Orthodox Women in the Ecumenical Movement, Geneva: WCC Publications, 2010. 244 p.
Tarasar C., Kirillova I. Orthodox Women. Their Role and Participation in the Orthodox Church, Geneva: WCC Publications, 1977. 226 р.
Himmel-Agisburg A. M. Ansatze zu einer orthodoxen Frauenbewegung // Kanon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. 2005. Bd. XVII. S. 3–27.
Fitzgerald K. K. Die Eva-Maria Typologie und die Frauen in de Orthodoxen Kirche // Internationale Kirchliche Zeitschrift. 1998. April — Juni. S. 226–232.
Ohme H. Neue theologische Einsichten der Orthodoxie zur Frage der Frauenordination — Die Konferenz von Rodhos vom 30.10 — 7.11.1988 // Bock W., Lienemann W. Frauenordination. Studien zu Kirchenrecht und Theologie. Heidelberg: FEST, 2000. Vol. III. S. 141–145.
Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew Hosts International Conference for Orthodox Women // STNINA. ORG: сервер журнала The St. Nina Quarterly. 1997. URL: http://www.stnina.org/printjournal/volume-1/volume-1-no-4-fall-1997/ecumenical-patriarch-bartholomew-hosts-international (дата обращения: 04.02.2018).
Fitzgerald K. K. Women Deacons in the Orthodox Church: Called to Holiness and Ministry. Brookline: Holy Cross Orthodox Press. 1998. 226 p.
Vasilevich N. Die Stille der Frauen am Heiligen und Gro.en Konzil // Religion & Gesellschaft in Ost und West. 2016. No. 11. S. 22–24.
Theodorou E. D. Weibliche Kleriker aus orthodoxer Sicht. Unter besonderer Berucksichtigung der Empfehlung der panorthodoxen Theologenkonferenz von 1988 // Kanon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. 2000. Bd. XVI (Mutter, Nonnen, Diakonissen). S. 190–212.
Bader D. Warum keine Ordination der Frau? Unterschiedliche Einstellungen in den christlichen Kirchen. Munchen: Schnell & Steiner, 1987. 187 S.
Hopko Th. Woman and Priesthood. Crestwood, NY: St Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1983. 260 р.
Evdokimov P. La femme et le salut du monde. Etude d’Anthropologie chretienne sur les charismas de la femme. Paris: Casterman, 1958. 272 p.
Jensen A. Wie patriarchalisch ist die Ostkirche? Frauenfragen in der orthodoxen Theologie // Una Sancta. 1985. Vol. 40. S. 130–145.
Meer H. van der. Priestertum der Frau? Eine theologie-geschichtliche Untersuchung, Freiburg: Herder, 1969. 213 S.
Gemeinsame Uberlegungen der Orthodox-Altkatholischen Konsultation zur Stellung der Frau in der Kirche und zur Frauenordination als okumenischem Problem. Vorbemerkung // Internationale Kirchliche Zeitschrift. Bild Christi und Geschlecht. 1998. April — Juni. S. 78–81.
Synek E. Frauenrolle & Frauenrechte in der Europaischen Orthodoxie // Каnon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. Bd. XVII. Egling: Roman Kovar, 2005. 265 S.
Vassiliadis P., Papageorgiou N., Kasselouri-Hatzivassiliadi E. (eds) Deaconesses, the Ordination of Women and Orthodox Theology. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2017. 610 p.
References
Beliakova, E., Beliakova, N, and Emchenko, E. (2011), Zhenshchina v pravoslavii: tserkovnoe pravo i rossiiskaia praktika [Woman in orthodoxy: Church Law and Russian Practice], Kuchkovo pole Publ., Moscow, Russia.
Barot, M. (1964), Cooperation entre les hommes et les femmes dans l’Eglise, la Famille et la Societe [Cooperation between men and women in the Church, the Family and Society]. Broshures d’Information sue se departament, COE, Geneva, Switzerland.
Limouris, G. (2000), “Orthodox and ecumenical Assemblies and Conferences of the 20th century”, Kanon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. Mutter, Nonnen, Diakonissen, vol. XVI, 4. Kunter, K. (2017), “Byl li tretii put’? Vsemirnyi sovet tserkvei v period kholodnoi voiny” [Was There a Third Way? World Council of Churches in the Period of Cold War], Gosudarstvo, religiia, tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom, vol. 35, no 1, pp. 147–163.
Ber-Sigel, E. and Ware, K. (2000), Rukopolozhenie zhenshchin v Pravoslavnoi tserkvi [The Ordination of Women in the Orthodox Church). Biblical-Theological Institute, Moscow, Russia.
Parvey, C. (ed.) (1983), The Community of Women and Men in the Church. The Sheffield Report, WCC, Geneve, Switzerland.
Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry. World Council of Churches. Faith and Order. Paper No. 111, WCCCOE. ORG: the site of World Council of Churches, available at: https://www.oikoumene.org/en/resources/documents/commissions/faith-and-order/i-unity-the-church-and-its-mission/baptism-eucharist-andministry-faith-and-order-paper-no-111-the-lima-text (Accessed 8 February 2018).
Was ist und was soll eine “Okumenische Dekade Solidaritat der Kirchen mit den Frauen”? (1996), Informations-und Studienheft fur die evangelische Landeskirche in Wurttemberg, Wurttemberg, Germany.
Brown, S. “Churches accused of ignoring or condoning violence against women”, ARCHIVE. WFN.ORG: server of the Worldwide Faith News Archives. Ecumenical News International. 1999. 04.01, available at: http://archive.wfn.org/1999/01/msg00030.html (Accessed 11 February 2018)
WCC Assembly Debates Role of Women. WCC Eighth Assembly — Press Release No. 16. 7 December, available at: http://wcc-coe.org/wcc/assembly/pre-16.html (Accessed 11 February 2018).
“Zakliuchitel’nyi otchet Spetsial’noi komissii po voprosu ob uchastii Pravoslavnykh Tserkvei v rabote Vsemirnogo Soveta Tserkvei” [The report of the Special Commission on the Participation of Orthodox Churches in the World Council of Churches], available at: http://wcc-coe.org/wcc/russian.html (Accessed 11 February 2018).
Liveris, L. B. (2005), Ancient Taboos and Gender Prejudice: Challenges for Orthodox Women and the Church, Routlege, Abingdon, UK.
Kasselouri, M. and Pekridou, M. (ed.) (2010), Many Women Were Also There: The Participation of Orthodox Women in the Ecumenical Movement, WCC Publications, Geneva, Switzerland.
Tarasar, C. and Kirillova, I. (eds) (1977), Orthodox Women. Their Role and Participation in the Orthodox Church, WCC Publications, Geneva, Switzerland.
Himmel-Agisburg, A. M. (2005), “Ansatze zu einer orthodoxen Frauenbewegung”, Kanon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. vol. XVII, pp. 3–27.
Fitzgerald, K. K. (1998) “Die Eva-Maria Typologie und die Frauen in de Orthodoxen Kirche”, Internationale Kirchliche Zeitschrift, April — Juni, pp. 226–232.
Ohme, H. (2000), “Neue theologische Einsichten der Orthodoxie zur Frage der Frauenordination — Die Konferenz von Rodhos vom 30.10–7.11.1988”, in Bock, W. and Lienemann ,W. (eds), Frauenordination. Studien zu Kirchenrecht und Theologie, vol. III. FEST, Heidelberg, Germany, pp. 141–145.
“Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew Hosts International Conference for Orthodox Women”, STNINA. ORG: server of The St. Nina Quarterly. 1997, available at: http://www.stnina.org/print-journal/volume-1/volume-1-no-4-fall-1997/ecumenical-patriarch-bartholomew-hosts-international (Accessed 4 February 2018).
Fitzgerald, K. K. (1999), Orthodox Women speak. Discerning the Signs of the Times. WCC, Geneve.
Vasilevich, N. (2016), “Die Stille der Frauen am Heiligen und Gro.en Konzil”, Religion & Gesellschaft in Ost und West, no. 11, pp. 22–24.
Theodorou, E. D. (2000), Weibliche Kleriker aus orthodoxer Sicht. Unter besonderer Berucksichtigung der Empfehlung der panorthodoxen Theologenkonferenz von 1988, Kanon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. Mutter, Nonnen, Diakonissen, vol. XVI, pp. 190–212.
Bader, D. (ed.) (1987), Warum keine Ordination der Frau? Unterschiedliche Einstellungen in den christlichen Kirchen, Schnell & Steiner, Munchen, Germany.
Hopko, Th. (ed.) (1983), Woman and Priesthood, St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, Crestwood, NY.
Evdokimov, P. (1958), La femme et le salut du monde. Etude d’Anthropologie chretienne sur les charismas de la femme [The woman and the salvation of the world. Study of Christian Anthropology on the Charismas of Women], Casterman, Paris, France.
Jensen, A. (1985), “Wie patriarchalisch ist die Ostkirche? Frauenfragen in der orthodoxen Theologie”, Una Sancta, vol. 40. pp. 130–145.
Meer van der, H. (1969), Priestertum der Frau? Eine theologiegeschichtliche Untersuchung, Herder, Freiburg, Germany.
“Gemeinsame Uberlegungen der Orthodox-Altkatholischen Konsultation zur Stellung der Frau in der Kirche und zur Frauenordination als okumenischem Problem. Vorbemerkung”, (1998), Internationale Kirchliche Zeitschrift. Bild Christi und Geschlecht, April — Juni, pp. 78–81.
Synek, E. (ed.) (2005), Каnon. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft fur das Recht der Ostkirchen. Frauenrolle & Frauenrechte in der Europaischen Orthodoxie, vol. XVII.
Vassiliadis, P., Papageorgiou, N. and Kasselouri-Hatzivassiliadi, E. (eds) (2017), Deaconesses, the Ordination of Women and Orthodox Theology, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Cambridge, UK. pp. 1–24.
Downloads
Published
2019-03-29
How to Cite
Белякова, Н. А. (2019). “Women’s issue” in Orthodoxy: discussions in the second half of 20th — 21st century. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies, 35(1), 194–208. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu17.2019.116
Issue
Section
Religious studies
License
Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
